Side-by-Side Router Compares Driving, Walking, Biking, and Transit

avatar
Michael is senior tech advisor for Mobility Lab. He specializes in photography and cool transportation visualizations, and he leads Transportation Techies DC.
January 18, 2013

Online mapping applications have become an essential tool for route planning.

The route planner from Google Maps originally assumed everyone wanted driving directions for cars, but has grown to include options for biking, walking, and transit. Availability depends on the location, but I’ve been impressed with Google Maps’ coverage.

Using Google’s “application programming interface” (API), I created a tool that lets you compare all four options at the same time.

I call it the Side-by-Side Router. Once you pick two end-points, the four modes’ routes are drawn with different colors. It’s been surprising to see how the routes vary depending on the mode. The program also gives you the total travel time and distance for each mode.

As an advocate for biking and transit, it was a bit disheartening to see the driving mode “win” when it came to creating the fastest trip. But the driving directions assume what is known as “Doris Day parking,” the phenomenon where one magically finds an empty parking space immediately in front of one’s destination. (For an example, turn to 0:59 in this clip.)

By comparison, the transit directions include getting to and from the transit station. When testing the transit directions in Colorado Springs, where my starting point was many miles from the nearest bus stop, I was surprised when the first step said to “drive/taxi to” the bus stop! Still, it’s a powerful tool.

Google Transit has accumulated about 500 cities that participate with the Google Transit Partner Program since starting as an experiment in Google Labs in 2005, and becoming integrated with Google Maps in 2006.

Take a minute to play with the Side-by-Side Router and see what you can learn about your environment. Does it reinforce the notion that the car is king, or does it open your eyes to alternate methods of transportation?

Read more about the program at Comparing Driving, Walking, Biking and Transit.

{ 6 comments… read them below or add one }

avatar Calgary Drivers Education January 21, 2013 at 4:08 PM

Wow that’s a really cool tool!

Reply

avatar joejoejoe January 22, 2013 at 10:33 PM

This is a great tool! Could you add some info about parking times at the end of routes.?There are plenty of 5 minute drives in the city that become 15 minute drives if you include the standard hassle of finding a parking spot.

Reply

avatar Paul Mackie January 23, 2013 at 12:51 PM

JoeJoeJoe,

We’ve had some articles about this on our website:
http://mobilitylab.org/2012/08/15/why-car-traffic-and-free-parking-are-bad-for-campuses/

And our friend Bern Grush, who is part of the Mobility Collaborative (http://mobilitylab.org/collaborative/), does great research on parking issues: http://grushhour.blogspot.com/search/label/Parking

Reply

avatar Mano Marks January 23, 2013 at 5:59 PM

Awesome site. Would be even better with the Places Library of the Maps API autocomplete functionality for the address entry.

Reply

avatar Barbara Robarts January 23, 2013 at 6:48 PM

Awesome! I bike much slower than your guy does, but old ladies with walkers and kids on tricycles pass me, so that is to be expected. . Ok, it’s not QUITE that bad, but close. This could be very handy!

Reply

avatar dices.es September 28, 2013 at 8:38 AM

interesting app planner for the mobility nowadays, thanks for the info!

Reply

Leave a Comment

*

{ 5 trackbacks }

Previous post:

Next post: